Lou Lumenick

Lou Lumenick

Movies

With ‘12 Years a Slave,’ Oscars get it right this year

Major props to the Oscars for acknowledging “12 Years a Slave” as the the Best Picture of 2013, reversing its recent trend of embracing less challenging fare like “Argo” and “The Artist.”

The top honor for this unflinching — and at times, hard to watch — look at America’s most shameful institution comes 74 years after “Gone With the Wind,” which romanticized slavery, became one of the academy’s most honored films ever.

The Best Picture win by “12 Years” — the first Best Picture winner directed by black man — wasn’t exactly a total surprise.

Like most of last night’s winners in the main categories, its victory was telegraphed in a series of earlier awards ceremonies that pretty much locked in all four of last night’s acting honorees by the end of January.

Just how close the vote could be between “12 Years a Slave” and the other frontrunner, “Gravity,” was clear when the Producers Guild of America awards announced that for the first time, there was a tie between the two of them.

A spokesperson for the Oscars vowed there wouldn’t be an unprecedented tie for the Best Picture Academy Award because of the complex preferential voting system it adopted four years ago.

When “Gravity” won the highly predictive Directors Guild of America award, there were widespread predictions that Oscar voters would split the two top awards — “12 Years a Slave” for Best Picture and “Gravity” for Best Director, Alfonso Cuarón.

That’s exactly what the British academy awards did two weeks ago. And I’m perfectly fine with the same split at the Oscars– the fifth so far this century. It’s the first time since 1949-1950 that there were back-to-back splits. “Argo” won Best Picture last year, at least partly because Ben Affleck was snubbed for a Best Director nomination, and the Best Director award went to Ang Lee for “Life of Pi.”

Like last year’s directorial winner, “Gravity” is a directorial tour de force, and a technical landmark. And it just happened to be the most popular of the nine nominees for Best Picture at the box office.

Ever since the academy expanded the Best Picture field four years, it’s had the odd effect of focusing attention on a smaller and smaller group of feature films.

While I can’t disagree with any of last night’s widely predicted acting winners  it’s noteworthy that three of the four performances (the exception was Cate Blanchett in “Blue Jasmine”) were in Best Picture nominees.

It sure would have been nice to have one or two of the surprises that used to be routine on Oscar night.

1 of 11
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture
The cast and crew of "12 Years a Slave" accept the award for Best Picture.Getty Images
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture
The cast and crew of "12 Years a Slave," including Sarah Paulson (left) and Lupita Nyong'o (right) accept the award for Best Picture.
Advertisement
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture
Brad Pitt and director Steve McQueen accept the Best Picture award for "12 Years a Slave."Getty Images
"12 Years a Slave" wins best picture
Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt share a moment before he accepts the Best Picture award for "12 Years a Slave."Getty Images
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture
Michael Fassbender and director Steve McQueen celebrate as they accept the Best Picture award for "12 Years a Slave."Getty Images
Advertisement
"12 Years a Slave" wins the award for Best Picture
Director Steve McQueen and Brad Pitt accept the award for Best Picture for "12 Years a Slave."Getty Images
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture.
Will Smith (right) congratulates Brad Pitt (left) as he accepts the award for Best Picture for "12 Years a Slave."Getty Images
"12 Years a Slave" wins Best Picture
Director Steve McQueen celebrates with the cast and crew of "12 Years a Slave" as they accept the award for Best Picture.AP
Advertisement